For as long as I can remember, I have dreamt of my wedding day; white gown, handsome man, cake, flowers, you name it. Most of the people I grew up with shared these dreams, so it never occurred to me until high school that many people do not share this marriage ideal. “Gay marriage?” I thought, isn’t that an oxymoron?
Since my period of ignorance and naivete, I have read many articles and heard many arguments supporting both sides of the marriage debate. From friends and family to Fox News and Huffington Post, I have attempted to assess each view on the issue. Last semester, I even wrote a nonpartisan article about the legislative trend in America to legalize same-sex marriage, civil unions, and the like.
Nonetheless, this weekend I got into a heated debate with my parents on the issue. My parents are Catholic and raised me Catholic, but I currently do not affiliate with any denomination. In addition, I went to a Catholic high school, so attending a fairly liberal state university was a major change. I was exposed to an institution, an education, and a group of people who have challenged me to examine my own beliefs in depth.
I have been a 'supporter' to some extent of the right of same-sex couples to have the same liberties and protections that heterosexual married couples do since my exposure to the idea. However my reasons for support were quite limited. I knew that everyone should have equal rights, whatever that meant, and that marriage is a religious union. It wasn't until the wave of red equal signs took over Facebook and sparked conversations between people that I read something that cleared the air for me. The post went along the lines of, 'even if the Church says that marriage is between a man and a woman, our country has both a separation of church and state and an amendment guaranteeing equal protection under the law.’
At that moment, I realized that what I truly support and what everyone deserves is a guarantee of the exact same legal rights. Every couple deserves equality regardless of the term the government chooses to use. The fact that both our federal and state governments choose to use the word marriage as a legal term has clouded all arguments. Rather than discussing the rights of two people, we discuss the rights of a 'married couple.' Why do two heterosexual people go to a courthouse and obtain a 'marriage license' if 'marriage' is of religious nature? If it was purely a religious matter, the two would go to a priest; legal documents would matter not.
Our country promises equal protection. The Defense of Marriage Act is the antithesis of this promise. It upholds a legal manifestation of a religious belief in a country whose citizens are as diverse in religion as they are in sexuality. From taxes to social security to immigration to health coverage, all unified couples should receive the same federal, state, and professional benefits. According to our government, the only way that two people deserve these benefits is if they subscribe to the dominant sexual orientation in our country and choose to unify. Yet simply because a couple is opposite-sex does not mean that their commitment to one another is more significant than a same-sex couple. If that principle is true, how can we explain people in second, third, and fourth marriages?
As a society, we must be more cognizant of the roots of our beliefs. We must be willing to question ourselves, examine our convictions, and determine whether our arguments are rooted in fact or in faith. No longer is it acceptable to deny rights to fellow Americans because their love looks different or because as a country we have blurred the lines between religion and rights. We must realize that America is not a melting pot whereby all parts blend to create a whole; rather we are a tossed salad in which each part deserves to be seen, represented, and valued for its diverse contribution.
I may dream of one day wearing a gown and signing my ‘marriage license’ with a man in a suit, but not everyone shares this dream. Men and women, both in suits or both in gowns, deserve to experience the same process and be awarded the same benefits as I. For we have not chosen the desires of our hearts, but we have chosen as a heterosexually-dominated society to use them in conjunction with religion to discredit the diverse desires of others.

0 comments:
Post a Comment