On this hump day of finals week, my plan was to take a quick scroll through my Facebook news feed then proceed to study for my two remaining exams. Little did I know that I'd run across a link to an article that struck a cord in my heart unlike any other I have seen this semester. If you know me, you may know that I am an only child. This awareness comes with knowing that I absolutely hate being an only child. I do not use the word hate lightly.
The aforementioned article references a study conducted to examine the effects of China's one-child policy on child outcomes. It compared people born before and after the policy's implementation using characteristics such as altruism, trust, and competitiveness. The sibling-less children born under the policy exhibited less of these qualities yet performed better at math, leading the article to call them "little emperors." In the same light, my friend shared the article and called them "the spoiled brats."
It was a combination of my friend's comment and the unfair implications alluded to by this article that upset me. The issue is twofold. These children could not control when they were born or the culture they grew up in. Secondly, one develops certain qualities and traits because of the environment they were raised in, the resources they had, and the way they were socialized.
These children did not set out to be little emperors. The policy did not grant each family a crown for their only child as he selfishly entered the world. Yes, these children likely had more toys per capita than children born with multiple siblings. Yet these children had no siblings. Granted, I am writing from the perspective of an American only child whereby the vast majority of other people my age had siblings to play with. Their 'family time' likely consisted of playing with siblings and cousins close to their age. While I had friends down the street whom I could play with, my 'family time' consisted of socializing with my parents and their friends. [Note: My father was also an only child and my mother had only one sibling, leaving me with three cousins. I rarely saw them for a span of about 10 years.]
At home, yes, it was all about me. I got the toys I wanted and could be involved in the sports I so chose because my parents did not have to allocate the money between three children. At night I did homework because I lacked the distractions of my siblings to lure me to play instead. Yet realizing what it truly means to be an only child truly hit me when my father's mother passed away. My father was an only child. He is physically and emotionally distant from his extended family. While he corresponds with them at times, they do not have a strong bond. So when my grandmother died, my father was alone. His father passed away before I was born, so my dad was the only one who knew his mother like he did, as a child she raised, as someone who provided him good times and not so good times.
I write about these personal experiences because growing up, I was often considered a "little emperor." As I have gotten older, more people begin to feel sorry for me because they realize in their maturity that their siblings are truly are the only people who have been raised similarly and exposed to the same things. When a child has no companions by blood or adoption, there is no one to compete with. He will likely trust others less because he had not experienced trust from a sibling, whether by trusting a sibling to keep a secret from their parents or by trusting that a sibling will follow through with experimenting with an adventurous endeavor.
We cannot let the framing of these statistics rule our view of the children born under the one-child only policy. Over time these children will learn to work together, and they will hopefully find comfort in knowing that their experience as an only child is not unique. It is unfair to label them as entitled brats when they could not control their family structure. I could not control mine either. Yet while I had to learn to cope with loneliness in the midst of multi-child families, these kids will realize that they need social partners and companions to bond with as they grow old.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

3 comments:
This is fascinating to me. I am an identical twin so even if I had not had older sisters, I would have never known loneliness because my twin has literally been with me since we were in my mom's womb. I am guilty of perceiving my friends that were only children as spoiled and bratty even after I knew that they did not choose their situation any more than I chose mine. Now that I am older I realize how much I took my siblings for granted. My parents are getting older and their health is not what it used to be. My older sister is taking care of my mom as issues arise because my twin sister and I are still in college. And I have realized that when they do pass away, I will have sisters to lean on. My friends that are only children will not have that and neither will all of those children in China. That is a humongous burden to carry but because most people are not only children, it is rarely talked about. Great post Melanie.
You've made some really wonderful connections between your experience as an only child and the policy in China affecting children. I have three siblings so this issue rarely crosses my mind. You opened up my mind a bit more on the matter. Thanks for sharing!
As an only child who has a so-called "little emperor" in her extended family, I feel so much for this post. My cousin is not an only child and he was born in America; however, he is the only son of my grandmother's oldest son. He is given highly preferential treatment, while his sisters had to live up to impossible standards.
It is not his fault. But it has made him into a 17 year old kid who has a lot of growing up to do. I hate pointing fingers, but... I can't help but feel like one person is to blame.
P.S. I hated being an only child too :(
-Heidi
Post a Comment